Is Man City's Post-2018 Era Built on Fair Play?
Examining whether Manchester City’s dominance after 2018 hides deeper financial rule breaches beyond the original 115 charges.
Football Content Creator & Sports Analyst
A new storm after the 115 charges
Manchester City had barely finished drafting their appeal against 114 guilty findings before a new question exploded across Premier League boardrooms: what about everything that came after?
The historic case reached only as far as the 2017 18 season. Yet most of City’s dominance, record breaking spending, and greatest trophies came after that cut off. The treble, five more league titles, the sustained era of Pep Guardiola’s super team, all sat outside the scope of the charges.
As the dust settled on the verdict, rival executives shifted from outrage to something colder and more strategic. If the pre‑2018 years were found to include serious rule breaches, what does that say about the financial reality of the City that ruled English football in the seasons that followed?
That question might be more dangerous than the original 115.
Life after the “sham sponsorship” era
The formal case centred on what investigators characterised as disguised equity funding and inflated commercial deals in the pre‑2018 period. PedTalks research indicates that several sponsorships were effectively reclassified as “sham” or related party arrangements that did not reflect genuine market value.
On paper, that era ended. In theory, the moment scrutiny landed, City’s books had to become squeaky clean.
Yet what happened next raised fresh eyebrows.
City’s revenues remained astronomical, even as some of the most controversial deals fell away. Commercial income kept pace with or outstripped on‑pitch success. Etihad, the headline sponsor at the heart of so much debate, continued to post massive losses that made independent observers question how any airline could justify the level of spending over such a long period.
At the same time, City’s transfer spending ramped up rather than eased off. They did not always smash single‑window records, but year after year the net spend and the wages assembled in east Manchester reflected the resources of a state. The squad evolved from excellent to absurdly deep, with two elite options in almost every position.
So rivals now ask a simple question. If the years that powered the first stage of City’s rise were found to involve serious rule breaking, how plausible is it that everything suddenly became perfectly organic and market driven from 2018 onward, just as the trophies poured in faster than ever?
Five titles and a treble under a cloud
From 2018 onward City became frighteningly familiar for the rest of the league: a domestic points machine, a squad that could absorb almost any injury crisis, and eventually the Champions League crown that had eluded them.
Those years created some of the most admired football the Premier League had seen. High pressing, shape‑shifting possession, full backs stepping into midfield, positional play refined to the extreme. On the whiteboard, it looked like a coaching masterclass.
But tactics do not exist in a vacuum. Rival executives watched a team that could replace a £100m winger with another £100m winger from the bench, all while staying on the right side of evolving financial rules.
What unnerved them was not simply the spending, but the timing.
Once the supposed “sham sponsorship” era ended, a normal business might tighten belts and move cautiously. Instead, City kept behaving like the most financially confident club in history, in a regulatory environment that had only grown harsher.
The APT trap and the Squad Cost Ratio squeeze
The landscape City dominated after 2018 is very different to the one they were originally charged over.
Advanced Profitability and Sustainability rules, often described as APT, are harsher and more focused on underlying economic reality. They try to limit clubs that simply pump external money into wage bills and transfers by forcing a closer link with genuine football income.
Alongside that sits the Squad Cost Ratio, which compares what a club spends on wages and transfers against what it earns. If your squad costs sprint far ahead of your revenues, regulators want to know why.
City insist they are compliant and argue that winning leads to revenue growth, which then supports elite squads.
Rival clubs are not convinced. They look at related party deals, at commercial partners with indirect links to the Abu Dhabi ownership, and question whether those arrangements truly belong in the same category as a global consumer brand paying for exposure.
The first case was largely about historic behaviour. The next battle, if it begins, would go to the heart of the current model. It would ask whether everything that turned City into the defining team of an era truly lined up with the spirit of financial fair play.
The compensation question that will not go away
Legally, the biggest fear for City is not just points deductions or historic title strips. It is money.
PedTalks sources suggest that several clubs have quietly mapped out potential compensation claims linked to City’s dominance during the charged years. If rival executives manage to tie any future wrongdoing to the post‑2018 era, when City hoovered up league titles and European prize money, the numbers on those spreadsheets would explode.
Think of the clubs who finished second to City, who missed out on Champions League spots, who lost broadcast and sponsorship value in a league effectively turned into a one‑club show. Each swing in league position can be worth tens of millions. Over multiple seasons, the theoretical damage claims become staggering.
That is why so many voices inside the game push for an extension of scrutiny into the post‑2018 era. It is not just ethics or sporting integrity, it is financial logic.
Yet there is a problem. The first wave of allegations did not fall out of the sky. They came from leaks, hacked emails, whistleblowers, accidental glimpses into how the machine worked.
Without another Football Leaks‑style event, regulators would need the will and political cover to go hunting aggressively through one of the sport’s most powerful clubs, based largely on suspicion and circumstantial trends. So far, that appetite seems limited.
Should the post 2018 books be opened?
Strategically, the Premier League faces an awkward choice.
If it opens a new investigation covering the post‑2018 seasons, it risks years more courtroom warfare with one of its flagship teams, along with the possibility that trophies and narratives are shredded after the fact. The league product, sold worldwide as a fair contest, would look more like a retroactive courtroom drama.
If it does nothing, it allows a lingering suspicion to fester. Every City title, every record, every tactical masterclass will sit inside quotation marks in the minds of many fans and rival clubs.
For City, the stakes are even higher. The 114 guilty findings already changed how their early success is remembered. A fresh probe into the dominant Guardiola years would strike at the heart of the project’s legacy.
From a governance perspective, the answer seems obvious. Yes, the Premier League should be willing to open the books again. Not as a witch hunt, but as a stress test for a model that reshaped English football more profoundly than any club project before it.
Without that transparency, the next problem for Manchester City is not only worse than the 115 charges. It is perpetual. Suspicion becomes the permanent soundtrack to every victory, and no amount of tactical genius on the pitch can drown it out.
Keep reading to earn your streak
Read each day to earn loyalty points and build your streak