PedTalksSports
HomeFOOTBALLThe EA FC Problem: Why Player Ratings Matter More Than Football Admits
The EA FC Problem: Why Player Ratings Matter More Than Football Admits
FOOTBALLPremium

The EA FC Problem: Why Player Ratings Matter More Than Football Admits

EA Sports FC 27 has Mbappé and Haaland rated 91, with Yamal, Kane and Rodri close behind. But have video-game ratings changed how fans judge real footballers?

PedTalksSports·August 20, 2026· 5 min read 6

A footballer can score 30 goals, win trophies and dominate the biggest matches of the season. Then EA Sports gives him an 89 instead of a 90 — and suddenly millions of people are arguing about whether he is overrated.

That sounds ridiculous.

It is also modern football.

The first major EA Sports FC 27 ratings have arrived, and Kylian Mbappé and Erling Haaland sit at the top of the men's game with 91 overall ratings.

Behind them is an extraordinary group rated 90: Rodri, Ousmane Dembélé, Vitinha, Harry Kane, Mi…

Premium Article

This content is for
Premium members only

Get full access to every article, exclusive deep dives, and ad-free reading from £5.99/month.

30% off annual plan · Cancel any time

FOOTBALLAnalysisPedTalks

Keep reading to earn your streak

Read each day to earn loyalty points and build your streak

How it works →

Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.